Metro Newspapers publishes weekly newspapers in California's Silicon Valley, Santa Cruz County and the North Bay. Metro's award-winning publications reach more than half a million readers in the San Francisco Bay Area every week.
Judge Orders County to Release Health Foundation Documents
Today's issue of Metro Silicon Valley sheds new light on how labor groups influence public policy in Silicon Valley
San Jose, CA, May 22, 2013 — The weekly newspaper Metro Silicon Valley has scored a victory for public transparency with Judge Carol Overton's ruling that the County of Santa Clara must release documents on the political activities of the nonprofit Santa Clara Family Health Foundation. Information from the documents appear in today's issue of Metro, and on the SanJoseInside.com website.
The documents, released to Metro on Friday, shed new light on how a recent ballot initiative was passed and how union-affiliated political groups interact with local nonprofits to influence public policy behind-the-scenes. "These are the Pentagon Papers of local politics," said Metro Executive Editor Dan Pulcrano. "For the first time, the public will see how groups here hatch schemes to tap the public treasury, as well as what they say in secret when they think their actions will never come to light."
The foundation refused to provide documents or grant interviews in March when Metro first wrote about a campaign to raise county taxes by a half-billion dollars over the next 10 years. A ballot initiative was approved by voters in November 2012. Directors of nine local non-profit organizations wrote a March 29 letter that attacked Metro's initial reporting on the political activity of two nonprofits as "bad for free speech."
On April 16, Metro filed a request for records under the California Public Records Act (CPRA). SCFHF responded ten days later with a letter denying the CPRA request. "Per the direction of our attorney, the PRA does not apply to the Foundation, as it is a private, nonprofit corporation. Therefore, the Foundation is not obligated to and hereby elects not to produce any records responsive to your Request. The Foundation now considers this matter closed," wrote Board Chair Dana Ditmore.
County officials disagreed, however. Noting that Santa Clara Family Health Foundation executive Kathleen King was a county employee and that the documents resided on county email servers, the county determined that the documents were public records that should be made available to the public. "Our position is they were clearly public records," county counsel Donald Larkin argued at the hearing.
SCFHF held an emergency meeting on on Monday, May 13 and sued the county on May 15 in an attempt to block the disclosure. (The county has access to the electronic records because the Health Foundation uses servers and email addresses of Santa Clara Family Health Plan, the public agency that established and provides office space to the non-profit foundation.)
"The Application is denied," Overton wrote in the May 17 Santa Clara County Superior Court ruling. "Petitioner has failed to establish that the subject records in the possession of Respondent are not public records within the meaning of the Public Records Act.
"Moreover, Petitioner has otherwise failed to substantiate its claim that it will be irreparably harmed unless the Application is granted." Metro was represented by noted First Amendment lawyer Judy Alexander.
The North Bay Bohemian picked up two awards at the Association of Alternative Newsmedia's 2012 annual convention in Detroit on June 8: a first-place award for Bohemian editor Gabe Meline in the category of Music Writing / Criticism, and a third-place award, also for Gabe Meline and his blog City Sound Inertia, in the category of Music Blog. This marks the third consecutive AAN win for City Sound Inertia, the Bohemian's music blog, which won first-and second-place awards in 2010 and 2011, respectively.
With these two awards in 2012, the Bohemian has won a total of 13 AAN Awards in the past 10 years, including awards for food writing, wine writing, special issues and music criticism.
Editor Gretchen Giles is among 12 U.S.
journalists to win a slot in the first
International Arts Journalism Institute
Billions in military contracts to husband's firms were approved by Sen. Feinstein's committee, Metro Newspapers investigation reveals
Metro Newspapers' web subsidiary acquires San Francisco city guide, SF Station
Metro Silicon Valley Launches PDF Download Edition.
News releases about Metro Newspapers
|Download this week's Metro|
Boulevards and Metroactive are registered trademarks or service marks of Metro Publishing Inc. or its affiliates. © 2009 All rights reserved.